UN and its Organ
UN & India
India, as a founding member of the United Nations, has consistently supported multilateralism, peacekeeping, development cooperation and global governance reforms. At UNGA 80, India again highlighted the need to make the UN more representative, inclusive and effective in addressing present-day global challenges.
About United Nations
- Meaning: The United Nations is an international organisation formed to promote global peace, security, cooperation and development.
- Founded: It was established on 24 October 1945.
- Headquarters: Its headquarters is in New York City, USA.
- Members: It began with 51 founding members and now has 193 member states.
- Objective: Its main aim is to prevent wars, maintain international peace, protect human rights and promote socio-economic progress.
- Role: It provides a platform for countries to resolve disputes through dialogue and cooperate on global issues.
- Main Organs: General Assembly, Security Council, ECOSOC, International Court of Justice, Secretariat and Trusteeship Council.
Main Organs of the UN
|
Organ |
Details |
|
General Assembly |
|
|
Security Council |
|
|
Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) |
ECOSOC coordinates work on economic, social, environmental and sustainable development issues. It has 54 members elected by the General Assembly. It coordinates 15 specialised agencies, 8 functional commissions and 5 regional commissions. |
|
Trusteeship Council |
The UN Trusteeship Council was created to supervise trust territories and help them move towards self-government or independence. Its work was completed when the last trust territory, Palau, became a UN member in 1994. Since then, the Council has suspended operations and meets only when necessary. |
|
International Court of Justice (ICJ) |
ICJ is the principal judicial organ of the UN. It settles legal disputes between states and gives advisory opinions on international legal issues. Structure of ICJ
Indian judges at the ICJ include Sir Benegal Rau, Nagendra Singh, R.S. Pathak and Dalveer Bhandari. |
|
Secretariat |
|
UN Peacekeeping
UN Peacekeeping is a key mechanism used by the United Nations to maintain global peace and security. It operates alongside other UN efforts, including conflict prevention, peacemaking, peace enforcement, and peacebuilding.
What It Involves
UN peacekeeping missions are deployed to support ceasefires and peace agreements. However, modern peacekeeping has evolved into a multidimensional effort that goes beyond military presence. It involves:
- Facilitating Political Processes: Supporting negotiations and governance structures.
- Protecting Civilians: Ensuring the safety of vulnerable populations in conflict zones.
- Disarmament, Demobilization, and Reintegration (DDR): Assisting former combatants in transitioning to civilian life.
- Election Support: Helping organize and oversee free and fair elections.
Human Rights and Rule of Law: Promoting justice, accountability, and governance reforms.
Role of Peacekeeping
Peacekeeping supports peace, conflict resolution, civilian protection, and post-conflict recovery. In some cases, peacekeepers may use force to enforce mandates and maintain security when the host state is unable to do so.
India’s Contribution to UN Peacekeeping
India has a long and distinguished role in UN peacekeeping, beginning with its participation in the UN operation in Korea in 1953. Guided by the ideals of non-violence and Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, India has consistently supported global peace and peaceful coexistence.
Since the 1950s, India has contributed over 2,90,000 peacekeepers to more than 50 UN missions, making it one of the largest contributors to UN peacekeeping. At present, over 5,000 Indian troops serve in 9 of the 11 active missions, and nearly 180 Indian peacekeepers have sacrificed their lives in the service of global peace.
Why UNSC Reform is Needed?
- Changed Global Reality: UNSC still reflects the post-1945 power structure, while today’s geopolitical and economic realities have changed.
- Poor Representation: Asia, Africa and Latin America remain under-represented in permanent membership.
- P5 Dominance: Veto power of the five permanent members limits democratic and effective decision-making.
- Need for Relevance: Without reform, UNSC risks becoming less relevant in addressing modern security challenges.
UNSC Reform Proposals
|
Reform Proposal / Issue |
Key Points |
|
Need for UNSC Reform |
UNSC still reflects the 1945 post-World War II power structure, while UN membership has expanded from 51 to 193 countries. Main reform issues include membership categories, veto power, regional representation, Council size, working methods, and Security Council–General Assembly relations. |
|
1965 Reform |
The only major UNSC reform took place in 1965, when non-permanent members were increased from 6 to 10. No major structural reform has happened since then. |
|
Razali Plan, 1997 |
Proposed by Razali Ismail, then President of the UN General Assembly. It suggested expanding the Council from 15 to 24 members by adding 5 new permanent members without veto and 4 new non-permanent members. It failed due to opposition from the Coffee Club/Uniting for Consensus group |
|
Kofi Annan Plan, 2005 |
In 2005, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan proposed expanding the UNSC to 24 members.
Annan urged member states to take a quick decision before the 2005 Millennium+5 Summit. |
|
G4 Proposal |
The G4 countries — India, Brazil, Germany and Japan — support each other’s demand for permanent UNSC seats. Their argument is based on economic strength, population, regional role and contribution to the UN. The UK, France, Russia and the US have supported G4 membership in different forms. |
|
African Group Demand |
The African Group demands 2 permanent seats for Africa, as Africa has no permanent representation despite being central to many UNSC agenda issues. The seats may be selected or rotated through the African Union. |
|
Uniting for Consensus / Coffee Club |
Led by countries such as Italy, Pakistan, Mexico, Argentina, Canada and Colombia. It opposes adding new permanent members. It supports expanding only the non-permanent category. In 2005, it proposed retaining 5 permanent members and increasing non-permanent members to 20. |
|
UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called for urgent UNSC reform, stating that the Council still reflects a bygone era despite major global changes. He stressed that reform must expand both permanent and non-permanent categories to make the UNSC more representative, effective and credible in protecting international peace, security and rule of law. |
|
India’s Claim for Permanent Membership in UNSC
Why India Deserves Permanent Membership?
- Global Power: India represents one-sixth of humanity and is among the world’s largest economies.
- UN Contribution: India has a long association with the UN and has contributed significantly to UN peacekeeping.
- Responsible Power: India supports disarmament, non-violence, peaceful coexistence and a rules-based global order.
- Active Global Role: India contributes to global issues like climate change, terrorism, pandemics, energy security and sustainable development.
- Asian Representation: India’s inclusion would strengthen Asian representation and balance China’s dominance.
India’s Efforts
- India, along with Brazil, Germany and Japan, formed the G4 to demand permanent UNSC membership.
- India’s bid has received support from major powers including the USA and France.
- In 2015, the UN moved towards Text-Based Negotiations on UNSC reforms
Indian Strategies
- Multi-layered Approach: India follows a strategy of gaining wider global support while reducing opposition within the UNSC.
- UNGA Support: India seeks maximum backing from the UN General Assembly, especially developing countries.
- P5 Engagement: India tries to minimise resistance from the five permanent members through strategic partnerships.
- Global South Leadership: India uses platforms like G-77, NAM and L-69 to build support among Asia, Africa and Latin America.
- Reform Groups: India joined the Friends on UN Security Council Reform to accelerate negotiations.
- Strategic Partnerships: India has strengthened ties with the US, Russia, France and other major powers to support its candidature.
Roadblocks for India
- China Factor: China may block India’s entry due to border disputes, BRI differences and regional rivalry.
- NPT and CTBT Issue: India’s refusal to sign the NPT and CTBT creates concerns among some countries.
- Limited Multilateral Resources: Weak socio-economic indicators and dependence on defence imports may affect India’s global image.
- Veto Power Dispute: Reform of UNSC remains difficult due to disagreement over the future use and expansion of veto power.
- Regional Opposition: Some countries, including Pakistan, oppose India’s permanent membership.
Way Forward
- India should take a more active stand on major global security issues.
- It should build a more coherent and consistent foreign policy approach.
- India must continue mobilising support from the Global South and reform-minded groups.
- Stronger engagement with the P5 is needed to reduce resistance.
- India’s inclusion would make the UNSC more democratic, representative and responsive to developing countries.